logo

Clean Air News

SearchRSS Feed

For Immediate Release:
3/16/2006
For More Information:
Contact Dena Mottola
(609) 394-8155 ext. 306

National Academy of Sciences Rejects Automakers’ Push to Restrict NJ Clean Air Standards

As the new home of NJPIRG's environmental work, Environment New Jersey can be contacted regarding this news release. 

TRENTON—NJPIRG on March 16 commended the National Research Council (NRC), an arm of the National Academy of Sciences, for resisting pressure from special interests to erode the ability of New Jersey and other states to protect their citizens from air pollution and global warming. In a report released on March 16, the NRC affirmed the vital role that states play in reducing pollution from cars, diesel trucks and other moving sources.

The auto industry had strongly urged the NRC to recommend that Congress change the Clean Air Act to create additional red tape for states that want to adopt more protective emission standards, including the Clean Cars Act, which New Jersey passed in early 2004 despite ferocious lobbying by the automobile industry.

“The states are leading the charge in reducing air pollution and global warming,” said Dena Mottola, NJPIRG’s Executive Director. “The last thing we need is for the federal government to create more red tape for states that are tackling these problems.”

Instead, the NRC concluded that the states’ efforts have improved air quality. The NRC did not recommend any legislative or regulatory changes in the current process by which states adopt emission standards—changes that would further restrict the states’ rights to protect citizens’ health.

New Jersey has adopted emission standards that are more protective than the federal standards for cars, light trucks and diesel trucks. New Jersey officially adopted the Clean Cars regulations in December of 2005 under Gov. Codey. The Clean Cars regulations will reduce air toxics by 23% by 2020 – the equivalent of taking half a million cars off New Jersey roads – and the regulations would reduce greenhouse gases by about 15% by 2020.

In February, NJPIRG released a report showing that the clean cars programs now in effect in 10 states will reduce global warming pollution by 64 million metric tons per year in 2020, an amount greater than the national emissions of more than 140 nations.

States have long been at the forefront of policies to reduce air pollution and global warming. Under the Clean Air Act, California—which suffers from the worst air pollution in the nation—has unique authority to adopt emissions standards for mobile sources that are more protective than federal standards. Other states with poor air quality can then adopt California’s more stringent standards.

In the report, the NRC states, “California has used its authority as Congress envisioned: to implement more aggressive measures than the rest of the country and to serve as a laboratory for technological innovation.” The NRC calls California’s more protective emission standards “a proving ground for new emissions-control technologies that benefit California and the rest of the nation.”

Overall, 15 states and the District of Columbia—which with California account for more than half of the U.S. population—have adopted one or more of California’s emissions standards for cars and light trucks, diesel trucks, or other mobile sources. In 2005 alone, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington adopted California’s rules to limit global warming pollution from passenger vehicles.

The NRC report stems from an amendment that U.S. Senator Kit Bond of Missouri inserted into the fiscal year 2003 omnibus appropriations bill, directing the NRC to study state practices in setting emission standards for cars, trucks, and other mobile sources of air pollution. Later in 2003, Senator Bond sponsored the first weakening of states’ authority under the Clean Air Act in the law’s 35-year history; the law now precludes every state but California from adopting more protective standards for the engines used in lawnmowers and garden equipment.

The report recommends that EPA expedite the process for reviewing California’s standards. The panel also considered ways to modify the process by which other states adopt California’s standards but did not agree on a specific recommendation.

In 2005, at least 16 states, including New Jersey, wrote to the NRC to urge the panel not to make it harder for states to tackle air pollution and global warming.

Nationwide, 159 million people live in counties that violate the national health standard for ozone “smog” pollution and 95 million people live in counties that violate the health standard for fine particle “soot” pollution. Cars, trucks, and other mobile sources are the largest source of smog pollution and major contributors to soot pollution. These pollutants cut short the lives of tens of thousands of Americans each year and contribute to serious respiratory and cardiovascular problems, including asthma attacks, lung cancer, and heart disease. In addition, mobile sources release one-third of the nation’s emissions of carbon dioxide, the leading global warming pollutant.