Safe For Swimming? Report

Safe for Swimming?

Released by: Environment New Jersey Research & Policy Center

The Clean Water Act, adopted in 1972, set the goal of making all of our waterways safe for swimming. Nearly a half-century later, Americans visiting their favorite beach are still met all too often by advisories warning that the water is unsafe for swimming. And each year, millions of Americans are sickened by swimming in contaminated water.

An analysis of fecal indicator bacteria sampling data from beaches in 29 coastal and Great Lakes states and Puerto Rico reveals that 328 beaches – more than one of every 10 beaches surveyed – were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that sampling took place in 2020.[i] More than half of all the 3,166 beaches reviewed were potentially unsafe for swimming on at least one day. Beaches were considered potentially unsafe if fecal indicator bacteria levels exceeded the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s “Beach Action Value” associated with an estimated illness rate of 32 out of every 1,000 swimmers.[ii]

To protect our health at the beach, policymakers should undertake efforts to prevent fecal pollution, including deploying natural and green infrastructure to absorb stormwater.

Fecal contamination makes beaches unsafe for swimming. Human contact with contaminated water can result in gastrointestinal illness as well as respiratory disease, ear and eye infection and skin rash.[iii] Each year in the U.S., swimmers in oceans, lakes, rivers and ponds suffer from an estimated 57 million cases of recreational waterborne illness.[iv]

Our beaches are at risk. Runoff from paved surfaces, overflows from aging sewage systems, and manure from industrial livestock operations all threaten the waters where Americans swim. These pollution threats are getting worse with climate change, as more extreme precipitation events bring heavy flows of stormwater.

·   Sprawling development has created more impervious surfaces that cause runoff pollution and has destroyed natural areas like wetlands that protect beaches from contamination. From 1996 to 2016, U.S. coastal regions added 4.2 million acres of development, while losing 640,000 acres of wetland and nearly 10 million of acres of forest.[v]

·   America’s sewage infrastructure is deteriorating and outdated. Many communities, particularly around the Great Lakes, still use combined sewers that were designed to discharge sewage directly to waterways during heavy rainfall. Sanitary sewers, which are designed to carry sewage alone, can also spill dangerous sewage if they are not properly maintained, and overflow as many as 75,000 times each year in the U.S.[vi]

·   The rise of factory farms has resulted in large concentrations of livestock manure that cannot be stored safely and is often overapplied to crops. All too often, rainfall washes excess manure from cropland into our waterways where it can put swimmers’ health at risk. Animal manure also can contain pathogens that are resistant to antibiotics, creating added risk to public health.[vii]

Of more than 3,000 beaches sampled for bacteria across the country in 2020, 328 were potentially unsafe for swimming on at least 25% of days that testing took place.

·   As of May 2021, sampling data for 2020 from 3,166 beaches in 29 coastal and Great Lakes states and Puerto Rico was available through the National Water Quality Monitoring Council’s Water Quality Portal.[1]

·   Of those beaches, 1,689 (53%) had bacteria levels indicating potentially unsafe levels of fecal contamination for swimming on at least one day, and 328 were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that sampling took place.

·   Swimmers could also be at risk at additional beaches where no bacterial testing was conducted or available through the Water Quality Portal.

Figure ES-1. Average percentage of potentially unsafe beach days in 2020 by county

“Average percentage” represents the average of the percentage of potentially unsafe days at each beach within a county.

Bacteria testing of ocean and Great Lakes beaches in every region of the country revealed days of potentially unsafe fecal contamination in 2020.

·   Among East Coast beaches, 837 beaches, or 47% of the 1,798 beaches tested, were potentially unsafe for at least one day in 2020. 113 beaches, 6% of those tested, were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that testing took place.

·   Among Great Lakes beaches, 297 beaches, or 60% of the 497 beaches tested, were potentially unsafe for at least one day in 2020. 59 beaches, 12% of those tested, were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that testing took place.

·   Among Gulf Coast beaches, 220 beaches, or 82% of the 268 beaches tested, were potentially unsafe for at least one day in 2020. 75 beaches, 28% of those tested, were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that testing took place.

·   Among West Coast beaches, 252 beaches, or 72% of the 351 beaches tested, were potentially unsafe for at least one day in 2020. 62 beaches, 18% of those tested, were potentially unsafe on at least 25% of the days that testing took place.

In every coastal and Great Lakes state and Puerto Rico, sampling revealed potentially unsafe levels of contamination in 2020. (The figures below are based on U.S. EPA’s Beach Action Value. Many states use other thresholds for beach closure and advisory decisions. Therefore, results presented in this report may differ from state reports on beach water quality. See Methodology for details.)

Table ES-X. Every state had beaches with potentially unsafe days in 2020

State

Beaches tested in 2020

Beaches with at least one potentially unsafe day

Beaches with at least 25% potentially unsafe days

Alabama

24

21

8

California

258

193

42

Connecticut

65

46

11

Delaware

23

4

1

Florida

266

185

13

Georgia

26

17

3

Hawaii

218

55

14

Illinois

41

32

12

Indiana

21

18

1

Louisiana

23

21

10

Maine

61

36

15

Maryland

62

34

6

Massachusetts

556

264

29

Michigan

196

69

15

Minnesota

46

23

2

Mississippi

21

21

16

New Hampshire

16

9

3

New Jersey

210

35

2

New York

340

172

15

North Carolina

210

87

7

Ohio

54

49

14

Oregon

19

18

14

Pennsylvania

8

8

2

Puerto Rico

34

28

5

Rhode Island

65

30

13

South Carolina

23

20

7

Texas

61

55

31

Virginia

49

29

4

Washington

74

41

6

Wisconsin

96

70

7

 

To ensure that all of our beaches are safe for swimming, policymakers should work to protect beaches from runoff and sewage pollution – including by stopping pollution at its source, and by protecting natural areas. Solutions include:

·   Dramatically increasing funding to fix sewage systems and prevent runoff pollution through natural and green infrastructure, including rain gardens, permeable pavement and green roofs.

·   Protecting wetlands, which filter out pollutants like bacteria, and streams, which flow to places where people swim.

·   Enacting moratoriums on new or expanded industrial-scale livestock operations, particularly in areas that threaten our beaches and other waterways.

Policymakers should also ensure that swimmers are presented with the best-possible information to make decisions regarding their health. Officials should expand funding for beach testing, to ensure adequate testing at all beaches. States should use EPA’s most protective “Beach Action Value” bacteria standard for making beach advisory decisions and should work to implement same-day bacteria testing and warning systems.